When the State Admits Error and the Defendant Still Loses: State v. Martinez and the Cost of an Unpreserved Objection

State Admits Error Defendant Still Loses

One of the hardest lessons in criminal defense is that being right is not always enough. A recent unpublished decision from the North Carolina Court of Appeals, State v. Martinez (COA23-905, filed December 17, 2024), illustrates this painful reality. The State conceded on appeal that it had improperly impeached the defendant with a conviction the rules of evidence flatly prohibit. The defendant still lost. Understanding why is essential for anyone facing trial in a North Carolina courtroom.

The case arose from a Brunswick County “controlled buy.” A confidential informant working with the sheriff’s office told officers she planned to buy five Suboxone strips from the defendant. A recording captured the defendant handing over a small package in exchange for a one-hundred-dollar bill. The defendant testified that the exchange was innocent—that the money was for alcohol and the baggie held Subway coupons. The jury did not believe her, convicting her of selling a Schedule III controlled substance and related charges.

The Rule 609 Violation Everyone Agreed Was a Mistake

On cross-examination, the prosecutor asked the defendant about a 2016 conviction for possessing drug paraphernalia. Under North Carolina Rule of Evidence 609, the State may attack a witness’s credibility with a prior conviction only when that conviction is a felony or a Class A1, Class 1, or Class 2 misdemeanor. A Class 3 misdemeanor does not qualify. On appeal, the State openly conceded that the 2016 conviction was a Class 3 misdemeanor—meaning the impeachment was improper.

So the trial court erred. The Court of Appeals said so directly. Yet the conviction stood. The reason lies in two procedural doctrines that quietly decide a great many criminal appeals: preservation and plain error.

Why the Objection Did Not Count

To challenge a ruling on appeal, a lawyer generally must object at trial and state the specific grounds, unless those grounds are obvious from the context. This is the preservation requirement of Appellate Rule 10. In Martinez, defense counsel objected to one question—whether the defendant was “legally able to purchase a firearm”—but did not object when the prosecutor went on to ask directly about the 2016 conviction.

The Court of Appeals held that the lone objection did not preserve the Rule 609 issue. It was aimed at a different question, and the court could not tell from the record why counsel had objected. As the court put it, a reviewing court will not speculate about an attorney’s unstated reasons. Because no proper objection was lodged when the conviction itself came in, the issue was reviewable only under the far more demanding plain-error standard.

The Steep Climb of Plain-Error Review

Plain error is not a friendlier version of ordinary appellate review. Following the North Carolina Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Reber (2024), the court explained that a defendant must show a fundamental error that had a probable impact on the verdict—meaning a different result was “almost certain” without the error, or “significantly more likely than not.” The court also emphasized that each alleged error is viewed in isolation, not for its cumulative effect alongside other mistakes.

“A close case is not enough to prevail on the prejudice prong of plain error.”

That single sentence decided Martinez. The court acknowledged that without the improper impeachment, this “may have been a closer case for the jury.” But a close case is not an almost-certain acquittal. Given the video evidence and the awkward fit between the defendant’s “Subway coupons” explanation and what the recording actually captured, the court could not say the jury almost certainly would have acquitted. The Rule 609 violation was real, conceded, and ultimately harmless under the plain-error test.

The Ineffective Assistance Claim and the Stricken Testimony

The defendant also argued ineffective assistance of counsel, pointing to her own lawyer’s decision to elicit testimony that she carried a gun without a concealed-carry permit. The court did not even reach whether that decision was deficient. Under Strickland v. Washington and State v. Braswell, a court may reject an IAC claim on the prejudice prong alone—and for the same reasons the Rule 609 error was harmless, the court found no reasonable probability the outcome would have changed.

Finally, the defendant tried to challenge the trial court’s decision to strike her testimony that the informant had been banned from Food Lion for stealing. Here the court found the issue waived twice over: the grounds were never developed at trial, and on appeal she offered only what the court called an “empty assertion of plain error,” without the specific argument and prejudice analysis that Appellate Rules 10 and 28 require. This mirrors the kind of evidentiary and preservation fights we discussed in our analysis of State v. Clark and the Confrontation Clause.

The Practical Takeaway

The lesson of Martinez is not that the rules of evidence do not matter—they clearly do. The lesson is that the rules only help a defendant who invokes them correctly and at the right moment. An objection must be specific, timely, and tied to the exact testimony at issue. When the moment passes, even a violation the State later admits may be reduced to “harmless” by a doctrine designed to leave most jury verdicts undisturbed.

This is why experienced trial counsel matters so much in serious cases, particularly drug prosecutions where credibility battles between an informant and a defendant decide the outcome. The record built at trial is the foundation of every appeal. Issues that are not preserved are usually issues that are lost.

If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges in North Carolina, the time to protect your rights is before and during trial—not after the verdict. The Chetson Firm represents clients in state and federal courts across North Carolina from our office at 19 W. Hargett Street in downtown Raleigh. Contact us to discuss your case with a board-certified specialist in state and federal criminal law.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top